Vegetables are our friends
And you’d better not forget it if you live in one of several American states that are implementing “veggie libel” or agricultural disparagement laws.
Under California’s proposed Assembly Bill 698 it will become illegal to say bad things about perishable agricultural products unless you hcan prove scientifically that your claims are true. Bills of this type introduce the same sort of rules for vegetables that currently exist for people as defamation laws.
There’s a huge amount of rubbish talked about food safety by various consumer and environmental groups and food producers claim that this can affect their incomes. The veggie libel laws got their start with the 1989 Alar scare, which suggested (once you trawled through the actual data) that people who consumed 20,000 litres or more of apple juice per day were liable to contract cancer. Apple growers claimed the affair cost them $100 million in lost sales but they lost a libel suit against CBS, who first aired the story.
Critics claim that the laws will be used to chill criticism of the food industry. In one case dairies were sued for advertising that their milk was growth hormone-free and thus implying that growth hormones are bad. The chilling effect occurs when the threat of a lawsuit prevents someone from expressing an opinion - even if they believe it to be true and have evidence to back it up - because they can’t afford to defend a lawsuit. These lawsuits (known in America as SLAPPs - “Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation”) have also caused publishers to back away from books because a book’s sales wouldn’t justify the legal costs, even if the case was won.
People behind food scares (and environmental scares more generally) can often be reckless with regard to the truth but it would be wrong to place a blanket ban on their utterings. The reputation of a vegetable should not have the same standing in law as the reputation of a person. This attempt can only be an act of professional courtesy on the part of California legislators.
The answer as usual is to have the debate in public, infuriating and tiring as that may be; to examine the evidence and then to point out in public, as P.J. O’Rourke did, that the Alar scare was not a problem with apples but with Meryl Streep’s head.
Hat tip: National Coalition Against Censorship.
June 22nd, 2007 at 1:53 am
html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/buy-phentermine.html buy phentermine buy buy phentermine online [URL=html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/buy-phentermine.html]buy phentermine[/URL] online
html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/Hydrocodone.html Hydrocodone cheap [URL=html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/Hydrocodone.html]Hydrocodone[/URL] buy Hydrocodone buy
order viagra order [URL=html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/order-viagra.html]order viagra[/URL] cheap html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/order-viagra.html order viagra online
[URL=html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/buy-hydrocodone.html]buy hydrocodone[/URL] pill html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/buy-hydrocodone.html buy hydrocodone online buy hydrocodone online
html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/viagra-online.html viagra online cheap viagra online buy [URL=html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/viagra-online.html]viagra online[/URL] cheap
html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/xanax.html xanax order [URL=html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/xanax.html]xanax[/URL] cheap xanax cheap
html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/buy-xanax.html buy xanax order [URL=html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/buy-xanax.html]buy xanax[/URL] online buy xanax cheap
cheap phentermine cheap [URL=html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/cheap-phentermine.html]cheap phentermine[/URL] online html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/cheap-phentermine.html cheap phentermine pill
[URL=html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/phentermine.html]phentermine[/URL] order phentermine order html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/phentermine.html phentermine order
generic viagra buy html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/generic-viagra.html generic viagra cheap [URL=html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/generic-viagra.html]generic viagra[/URL] pill
phentermine online buy html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/phentermine-online.html phentermine online order [URL=html://google.com/translate_c?u=golden-keys.net/pp/phentermine-online.html]phentermine online[/URL] buy
November 11th, 2007 at 12:44 am
I have visited your site 731-times
January 8th, 2008 at 5:07 am
free hot sex stories
relatively early death in February 2003 fuels the debate about the
January 11th, 2008 at 1:28 am
fake nude celebrities
Program created by the non-profit Dollywood Foundation that selects books
January 25th, 2008 at 4:02 am
Free Horse Sex
An English-language quarterly magazine targeting professional
January 26th, 2008 at 12:56 am
Asian Cum
Jon Tester is a third-generation Montana farmer who understands
March 8th, 2008 at 4:39 am
free cingular ringtones and graphic
Am nokia 3360 ringtones unlimited music ringtones
March 9th, 2008 at 8:27 am
poker online italiano
Se come giocare a poker gioco carte poker
March 12th, 2008 at 1:48 am
casino online postepay
Ci all slots casino casino download gratis
March 12th, 2008 at 2:08 am
roulette game download
Primo casino online it casino online gratis
March 29th, 2008 at 9:45 am
Hentai Dog Sex
Sebold was raped as a college freshman, but the police said she was
April 4th, 2008 at 10:08 pm
Animal Horse Porn Sex Woman Beastiality
Visit Sports.com today for unparalleled Sports Betting, Sports Odds and Sports Gambling.
April 5th, 2008 at 12:25 am
Dog Women Sex
explore all World Sport topics ». Top World Sport Stories